Name: Redskin Potato Salad
Prep time: 20 min
Cook time: 20 min
Ingredients: 2 lb red potatoes; 3 eggs; 1 rib celery (diced); ½ c light mayonnaise; 1 TB Italian dressing; ½ tsp salt; 1/8 tsp pepper

Jump to Recipe

Summer is potato salad season

Does anything say summer more than potato salad? (Okay, maybe ice cream, popsicles, shorts, sandals, suntan lotion – you get the idea…)

I have a true love affair with potatoes, particularly the red skinned variety and therefore redskin potato salad. Also, I believe that everyone should have at least one “go to” potato salad recipe that they love and can rely upon. (I have three, at last count)

potato salad ingredients in a bowl before mixing

There are many different potatoes and ways to make the dressing, and you might have your own preferences, but here are mine:

Ingredients for Red Skin Potato Salad

Potatoes: I use red potatoes, baby-sized if possible. The reason? It’s such a bother to peel potatoes! I leave the thin red skins as part of the salad. (Maybe this should be called Classic Potato Salad - Lazy Style.)

Eggs: Yes, mandatory for me. I use a ratio of 3 eggs to 2 pounds of potatoes.

Celery: Some feel this is optional, but I like the crunch.

Onions: I do not include onions (personal preference) but you can easily add some as preferred.

Dressing for potato salad

There are so many ways people make the dressing! Mayo is the base, some add yellow mustard and many variations of spices. I simplify all that and just use mayo, Italian salad dressing, salt and pepper. Simple! Works every time.

Cook the potatoes and eggs

To start, prepare your potatoes by cleaning them well, then cut into equal-sized pieces. Note: you are not making these bite-sized, just uniform in size so they cook evenly. I take the smallest potato in the bunch and cut it in half. This then becomes the approximate cooking size for all the rest. Similar small ones will be cut in half, large ones in fourths.

Place potatoes in a large pot of water, salted (1 TB), on your stovetop. All potatoes should be underwater. Turn heat on high and bring the water to a boil. Then turn the heat down to keep the water simmering. Simmer for about 15 minutes. Take a sharp knife and pierce a few pieces to check “doneness.” If the knife cuts easily, your potatoes are done. Larger pieces might need another 5 minutes or so. You want the potatoes to be cooked through but not mushy.

Boil the eggs in a separate pan for 10 minutes.

Once potatoes are cooked, drain them in a colander. Fill the pan you used for boiling with very cold water (add ice), then place the potatoes in the cold water to stop the cooking. You can also submerge the boiled eggs in this ice water to cool them down (it makes them easier to peel.)

Mix the potato salad dressing

In a small bowl, mix the mayo, Italian dressing, and salt and pepper until smooth; set aside.

Put the potato salad together

Once the potatoes are cool enough to handle, cut them into bite-sized pieces and place in a large bowl. Peel the eggs, then cut them into bite-sized cubes. Dice the celery. Add eggs and celery to the bowl with the potatoes.

Pour the dressing into the bowl and stir gently until all ingredients are evenly distributed.

Serve with all of your summertime meals! Maybe with some Juicy Lucys!

Redskin potato salad on a plate with a green salad and grilled chicken

5 from 41 votes

Print Pin it!